13 April 2018
The Batman Greens fall-out continues
The state of civil war within the Victorian Greens doesn't seem to be subsiding at all.
On May 11th, former Greens Councillor, who also stood as a candidate for the seat of Narre Warren South at the 2014 Victorian State Election, Lynette Keleher, took aim at the party and blasted it for what she describes as a culture of bullying and abuse.
I, as someone else who was heavily involved in the party; I can only say that Keleher is absolutely spot on in her assessment of the Victorian Greens.
By and large, the party's membership can be divided into two camps. The first camp is what can be considered the 'old guard'; consisting of people who have helped build the party from its humble beginnings in the early 1990's, on the basis of activism, as well as other people who have come in around them up to the present day. People such as Alex Bhathal and Lidia Thorpe both fall into this grouping.
The other, and more concerning, broad group can be termed as the 'new guard'. This group consists of several sub-groups, based on when and how they came into the party.
The first big subgroup are those who came into the party post 2001, jumping ship from both the Labor and Liberal Party's in response to the bypartisan me-tooism between the two major parties on Tampa and the Iraq War. These people, while broadly progressive and left-wing; were also broadly dismissive of social movements and their role in creating change, believing that progressive change comes from electing people into parliament. They brought with them the same attitudes and culture of opportunism and careerism that plagues the major parties, into the Greens.
The second big sub-group of the 'new guard' consists of former Democrats (some who held key positions in that party) who jumped ship following their demise as a political force. It is this sub-group that has been broadly responsible for the Greens centrist drag and willingness to do deals - seeking to turn the Greens into the Democrats 2.0, claiming to have learned from their mistakes of the past.
The third sub-group consists of a loose collective of younger people from affluent backgrounds, who grew up in Liberal voting households. In their adult lives, these people have only ever known the Greens. These people are very individualist, inward looking, ambitious and are very much motivated by career progression rather than activism, social movements, issues advocacy and party building.
It is the 'new guard' that now has dominance within the Victorian Greens and it was this group that gained confidence and was emboldened by the elevation of Richard Di Natale into the Federal Parliamentary Leadership. This group, which now occupies most of the key internal positions in the Victorian Greens, has been consistently and aggressively going after the 'old guard' in the party ever since as well as successfully taking power away from the grassroots membership and centralising it. Which is why...
...this statement, in a letter to The Age on May 13 by 'long standing Greens member' Colin Smith is completely misguided.
The fact is, the progressive green-left aren't really being given a choice. They are being forced out of the party unless they toe the centrist line and the party's 'new guard' couldn't care less about the work that has been put in to build the party over the years.
The party may not be entirely a powerful elite - but this powerful elite definitely have the most influence within the party.
|Total comments: 0|